With Louisiana residents going through sky-high auto insurance coverage premiums, state lawmakers are scrutinizing a state law that many say has prevented full transparency in jury trials on private harm circumstances.
5 legislative committees with oversight of insurance coverage and lawsuits met Wednesday as a part of a collection of hearings to analysis the causes and potential options to the state’s insurance coverage disaster. Legislators are anticipated to carry a particular session on insurance coverage points subsequent yr.
Auto insurance coverage charges in Louisiana are among the many highest within the nation and have been for a few years. One current analysis ranked the state because the eighth most costly for automobile premiums.
Talking to lawmakers on the Home Insurance coverage Committee, Commissioner of Insurance coverage Tim Temple mentioned Louisiana has double the nationwide common of auto insurance coverage claims with bodily harm.
Why Louisiana has so many extra bodily harm claims — and to what extent that impacts insurance coverage charges — is among the many myriad points legislators are investigating.
Temple mentioned he’s trying to Florida for instance, the place its lawmakers just lately handed a collection of legal guidelines with trade help that limit the options of policy holders.
Who’s to blame for Louisiana’s high insurance rates? Opinions are split.
The elements driving these excessive premiums have been the topic of debate for years. Insurance coverage firms have sometimes been unwilling to share all of the variables that go into their formulation for calculating auto premiums. Consequently, lawmakers have needed to depend on info from lobbyists and legal professionals.
Insurance coverage firms blame the excessive charges on state legal guidelines they are saying have incentivized accident victims to file lawsuits in opposition to them. They’ve lengthy referred to as for “tort reform” or measures that restrict the flexibility of individuals injured to hunt treatment and the quantity of damages they may obtain in courtroom.
Proponents of tort reform direct their ire at trial attorneys, whom they confer with as “TV legal professionals” or “billboard attorneys” and what they name their opportunistic purchasers.
“I feel there was a mentality of it’s a chance to get a fast inflow of cash, so many individuals that in all probability might haven’t gone to the physician and been effective in a few weeks instantly go to an legal professional,” Rep. Brian Glorioso, R-Slidell, mentioned. “The TV legal professionals drive that trade, and that’s the place the prices are.”
Private harm legal professionals who symbolize accident victims blame the excessive charges on a large number of things. Sen. Royce Duplessis, D-New Orleans, who’s a private harm lawyer, cited company government salaries, advertising and marketing prices and poorly maintained roads as elements driving premiums.
The Senate Insurance coverage Committee heard testimony concerning how medical bills are dealt with throughout jury trials on private harm lawsuits.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Doran Drummond, a Louisiana legal professional who specializes on the subject on behalf of insurers, mentioned a state statute that stops juries from receiving proof that reveals the precise prices of a sufferer’s medical bills. The jury is simply allowed to see evidence from the plaintiff concerning the billed quantity for a medical expense.
The issue, Drummond mentioned, is that the billed quantity might be artificially inflated past the quantity really paid for medical therapy.
Private harm legal professionals typically have standing agreements with medical doctors to whom they ship their purchasers to for medical exams and procedures. Slightly than amassing rapid cost from the accident sufferer, the medical doctors create artificially inflated invoices for the legal professionals to make use of as proof at trial, based on Drummond.
The jury finally ends up awarding a excessive quantity primarily based on these billed quantities, and the legal professionals ultimately give a few of that again to the medical doctors. However it’s nonetheless properly beneath the unreal quantity on the bill, Drummond mentioned.
The plaintiffs, themselves, are unaware of how all the pieces is being paid and are merely following the route of their attorneys, he mentioned.
“Take into consideration how this performs out over time in hundreds and hundreds of circumstances,” Drummond mentioned. “… How does that not drive everybody’s auto insurance coverage up?”
Sen. Kirk Talbot, R-River Ridge, advised laws that will both do away with the statute that shields precise medical prices or amend it to permit juries to see proof of the quantities billed in addition to the quantities really paid for medical bills.
Beneath questioning from Duplessis, Drummond revealed that he got here to testify on the request of the Louisiana Affiliation of Enterprise and Business.
LABI was chargeable for spearheading the tort reform legislation in 2020. On the group’s urging, lawmakers handed a number of payments that equally took away authorized instruments that accident victims needed to combat insurance coverage firms in courtroom. LABI promised the modifications would scale back auto insurance coverage charges rapidly and considerably, by as a lot as 25%.
Not solely did these reductions fail to materialize, however insurance coverage charges actually increased, and lawmakers have made no vital efforts to roll again the modifications.
Duplessis mentioned Drummond’s arguments had been primarily based on anecdotes. Lawmakers have but to see any causal proof or actuarial information that signifies whether or not private harm lawsuits or anything are guilty for top premiums within the state, the senator mentioned.
Talbot mentioned the hearings have solely simply begun and advised such proof might floor at a later date. The Senate Insurance coverage Committee plans to satisfy each month till subsequent yr’s common session, he mentioned.
The present legislation makes Louisiana an outlier amongst most different states, based on Talbot.
Alabama has “full transparency” relating to the medical billing evidence juries get to see, he mentioned. Talbot additionally famous Tennessee permits defendants to current proof of the common or reasonable costs of medical procedures in a selected ZIP code, an idea the legislation calls “ordinary and customary” prices.
Louisiana’s liberal perspective towards distracted driving can be an issue, a number of lawmakers and advocates famous in the course of the Home Insurance coverage committee.
Conservative lawmakers have repeatedly rebuffed makes an attempt to move laws prohibiting the usage of hand-held units reminiscent of cellphones whereas driving. In accordance with information introduced to the committee by the Louisiana Division of Transportation and Improvement, distracted driving was an element in additional than 30% of crashes in Louisiana from 2021-23.
“I personally consider that it contributes to [accidents],” Temple mentioned. “If you happen to’re your telephone, you’re not trying on the street.”
